0
Facebook
Volume 86 Issue 37 | pp. 11-18
Issue Date: September 15, 2008

Cover Story

Ion Mobility-Mass Spec Combo

Adding ion mobility to mass spectrometry brings new levels of separation and information to analyses
Department: Science & Technology
News Channels: Analytical SCENE
[+]Enlarge
Great Lengths
Indiana University graduate student Samuel Merenbloom works at a high-resolution IMS/MS instrument.
Credit: Courtesy of David Clemmer
8637cov_opencxd_opt
 
Great Lengths
Indiana University graduate student Samuel Merenbloom works at a high-resolution IMS/MS instrument.
Credit: Courtesy of David Clemmer

THE GROWING USE of ion mobility spectroscopy in conjunction with mass spectrometry in academic labs and commercial instrumentation is making the powerful MS technique even more capable. In addition to providing an extra dimension of separation, ion mobility provides shape information because that separation is also based on the conformation of a molecule rather than on its mass alone.

Despite the extra information that can be acquired from adding an ion mobility component to a mass spectrometric analysis, the combination was initially slow to catch on. Researchers had to build their own instruments, relegating IMS/MS to the labs of instrument jocks. But now, commercial instruments incorporating variants of IMS peddled by Waters Corp. and Thermo Fisher Scientific are bringing the technology into the mainstream. Waters' instrument, called the Synapt High Defintion MS System, uses a form of IMS called traveling-wave IMS. Thermo Fisher offers its system, based on high-field asymmetric waveform IMS (FAIMS), as a front end for its quadrupole and ion trap mass spectrometers.

In conventional IMS, also known as drift-time IMS, ions travel through a gas-filled drift tube that has a low applied voltage. Collisions with the gas molecules slow the ions in a way that depends on their conformation. The time an ion takes to traverse the tube, known as its drift time, can be used to calculate the ion's collision cross section, a fundamental property of the ion related to its size and shape.

[+]Enlarge
T-Time
Synapt's Tri Wave traveling-wave ion mobility device is located between the quadrupole and time-of-flight mass analyzers of a tandem mass spectrometer.
Credit: Waters
8637cov_4
 
T-Time
Synapt's Tri Wave traveling-wave ion mobility device is located between the quadrupole and time-of-flight mass analyzers of a tandem mass spectrometer.
Credit: Waters

Compact ions move through the drift tube faster than stretched out ones. Even for those researchers who don't care about the shape of the ions, this separation mechanism, when combined with MS or liquid chromatography/MS, allows many more components to be resolved in a single analysis than either of those other techniques alone.

In its recent rise in popularity, the IMS/MS combination first won converts in the protein structural biology community. Michael T. Bowers of the University of California, Santa Barbara, credits the introduction of the Synapt system with raising the community's awareness of IMS. "It's an opportunity to understand folding and aggregation of interacting systems, neither of which you can do with just mass spectrometry itself," he says. Bowers uses IMS/MS to study the early stages of protein aggregation that lead to fibril formation in a number of diseases, including Alzheimer's, Parkinson's, and type 2 diabetes.

IMS/MS is also making inroads in the area of imaging MS, in which mass spectral data are used to map the spatial distribution of compounds. Waters sells an imaging system using its Synapt platform.

Separation Power
The combination of FAIMS and IMS reveals more protein conformers, as indicated by the white boxes, than either technique alone. The temperature at the FAIMS-IMS interface varies from low (left panel) to high (right panel).
Credit: Anal. Chem.
8637cov_3-group
 
Separation Power
The combination of FAIMS and IMS reveals more protein conformers, as indicated by the white boxes, than either technique alone. The temperature at the FAIMS-IMS interface varies from low (left panel) to high (right panel).
Credit: Anal. Chem.

Combining IMS with MS results in more accurate images, says John A. McLean of Vanderbilt University. "In the context of imaging tissues, you have so many molecules with the same mass, but they're completely different," he says. The structural information provided by IMS sharpens the image, he adds.

McLean's team has collaborated with Richard M. Caprioli's group at Vanderbilt to do imaging IMS/MS. In a proof-of-concept experiment, they deposited overlapping lines of a peptide and a lipid with the same nominal mass in an X-shape on a piece of liver tissue. An image of an X is obtained, based solely on mass results. When mass and drift time are both used, the individual lines containing only the peptide or lipid appear (J. Mass Spectrom. 2007, 42, 1099).

One field that has been slow to adopt IMS/MS has been proteomics, but IMS proponents think that will change. Brandon T. Ruotolo, a research fellow working with Carol V. Robinson of the University of Cambridge, has been surprised by the lack of proteomics publications. "I'm sure it's out there in the wings," he says, "but I imagined it would be the first thing to come out."

McLean attributes the slow adoption in the proteomics community to practical issues. "I get the feeling that a lot of the proteomics core facilities are already invested so heavily in their technologies—huge numbers of mass spectrometers and LC systems—that their reaction time to new technology is going to be slower," he says.

McLean thinks, however, that proteomics researchers will be won over by the strengths of the method. "Mobility is beautiful at being able to separate chemical noise from putative peptide and protein signals. You can search genome and proteome databases with signals that you know, on the basis of structure, are peptides," he says. "Your confidence-level scores increase dramatically simply because you aren't searching those databases with peaks that you know are not peptides."

Method Development

Overtones Filter By Shape To Improve Sensitivity, Resolving Power

A new ion mobility technique uses the frequency of the applied field to selectively transmit ions through a drift tube. David E. Clemmer of Indiana University, Bloomington, predicts that the technique will improve the resolving power and sensitivity of IMS. In June, he described the method, called overtone mobility spectrometry, in a talk at the American Society for Mass Spectrometry meeting in Denver.

Clemmer realized that modulating the frequency of the drift field could turn a segmented drift tube into a continuous ion filter. Only those ions whose mobilities were resonant with the experimental conditions would be transmitted through the drift region. Ion mobility could then be interfaced with a continuous ion source, such as electrospray ionization, without having to worry about losing ions between pulses.

Clemmer, however, neglected to remind his students, Fabiane Nachtigall and Ruwan Kurulugama, that the fundamental frequency would be at the reciprocal of the drift time. Instead of looking at the fundamental frequency for their test ion, they scanned the frequency as far as their scanner would go, to 50,000 Hz. The resulting spectrum was filled with peaks they hadn't seen before. "It didn't take long for us to realize that these were overtone peaks," Clemmer said. The overtone peaks were much sharper and farther apart than the peaks at the fundamental frequency.

"Once you see these overtones, you realize you've built something analogous to a quadrupole mass filter," Clemmer said. "You can predict where the mobilities will come out. It's based on shape-to-charge rather than mass-to-charge." Thus, they could use the fundamental property of mobility to tune the filter to transmit only the desired species, and they didn't need to empirically determine the frequency required.

At the overtone frequencies the resolving power increases as the peaks move apart by a multiple of the difference between them at the fundamental frequency. For example, two peaks separated by 800 Hz at the fundamental frequency will be separated by five times 800 Hz, or 4,000 Hz, at the fifth overtone. Clemmer was able to separate the isomeric trisaccharides raffinose and melezitose at the fifth overtone but not at the fundamental frequency.

McLean himself is using IMS/MS to combine various "omics" techniques into a single analysis. "When people do things like glycomics versus proteomics and lipidomics, they try to purify each of the molecular classes ahead of time and then analyze them by mass spectrometry," McLean says. "With IMS/MS you can rapidly analyze something as complex as a cancer biopsy and see which masses correspond to peptides, lipids, or carbohydrates. You can really integrate all of those 'omics' strategies." This integration is possible because the different classes of biomolecules lie along their own "trend lines" in a plot of drift time versus mass-to-charge ratio.

SOMETIMES, however, the trend lines become blurred. McLean is developing "shift tags" to tease apart these overlapping trend lines. These tags alter the mobility characteristics of biomolecules. The current shift tags consist of positron emission tomography labels with a chelating ring that binds lanthanide metals with high affinity. In phosphoproteomic experiments the tags can be used to distinguish phosphorylated from nonphosphorylated peptides. Multiple states, such as diseased versus normal tissue, can be analyzed by using a different lanthanide for each one.

Likewise, Richard D. Smith of Pacific Northwest National Laboratory uses standard IMS as a way to increase the coverage and throughput of proteomic and metabolomic measurements. Although IMS reduces the need for a chromatographic separation, Smith prefers to use a fast liquid chromatography separation, as well as IMS. "That combination gives us a two-dimensional overall separation power that would take us a couple of hours to achieve with the best LC separations we can manage," he says. "This provides an order-of-magnitude increase in throughput, along with comparable or better proteome coverage."

Bowers calls IMS/MS "perfect" for proteomics. "The millisecond separation timescale works perfectly with any initial separation devices and any microsecond time-of-flight mass analyzer," he says. "I bet in five to 10 years, every mass spec-oriented proteomics facility will have associated with it an IMS."

Another hurdle for IMS/MS in the proteomics arena is data analysis. "If you've got mass-to-charge, you've got a lot of data," Bowers says. "If you've got mass-to-charge and shape—wow! Look at the tremendous amount of data you've got. Handling the data from a computational point of view is going to be significant."

So far, researchers are using IMS/MS mainly for biological applications, but McLean foresees other applications such as polymer analysis. For example, McLean and David M. Hercules, an emeritus professor at Vanderbilt, used IMS/MS to separate linear and branched aramids, the type of polymer used in Kevlar. No good techniques exist for being able to tell the branching ratio of these polymers, McLean says. The conventional way to do the analysis, he notes, is with gel permeation chromatography in concentrated sulfuric acid.

The commercial IMS instruments incorporate variations of ion mobility. In the FAIMS technique used by the Thermo Fisher instruments, the waveform applied between two concentric cylindrical electrodes alternates between high and low voltages. In one direction the ions experience a drift component much like in standard ion mobility, albeit at much higher field strengths. In another direction the ions experience an electrical displacement that threatens to send them crashing into the electrodes. Applying a direct current voltage, called the compensation voltage (CV), allows only certain ions to traverse the gap between electrodes. This CV is scanned to allow different ions to exit the gap. In this way FAIMS acts as a differential mobility filter just as a quadrupole mass analyzer acts as a mass-to-charge filter.

Waters' Synapt instrument employs a method called traveling-wave (T-wave) IMS. In this version the cell is made of a series of ring electrodes. Rather than a low electrical field being applied uniformly across the cell, a high electrical field is swept sequentially from one electrode to the next in the direction of ion migration. This electrical field separates the ions according to their mobility.

The constantly changing field makes it nearly impossible to determine the path length and collision frequency, two parameters that are needed to determine the collision cross section. Users who want to obtain a collision cross section to calculate the size of the molecule must calibrate data from a traveling-wave device against mobility data obtained with a standard drift cell.

FAIMS is the least understood of the ion mobility methods. "It depends on how the mobility changes with field as opposed to just the mobility," says Richard A. Yost, a chemistry professor at the University of Florida. "It doesn't have as much of a fundamental grounding as basic IMS understanding. The trade-off of the relatively simple fundamental understanding of IMS is that FAIMS offers you more potential to affect the separation by changing parameters."

THE LACK OF a theoretical understanding means that identifying the necessary CV for a given ion remains an empirical exercise. "You infuse a compound, ramp the compensation voltage, and find out at what CV the compound emerges from FAIMS," says James Kapron, a strategic marketing specialist at Thermo Fisher.

Even without such theoretical underpinnings, however, FAIMS provides an analytical boost for a wide range of applications. For example, it is used for sports doping analysis, Kapron says. It is also being used for pharmaceutical analysis in combination with LC/MS to remove interferences for added selectivity.

Smith's group is one of the few that uses both FAIMS and traditional IMS in the same experiment. "They turn out to be significantly orthogonal in how they separate ions," he says.

Front End
In the FAIMS interface selected ions generated by an electrospray probe (H-ESI) traverse the gap between the inner and outer electrodes to reach the mass spectrometer inlet.
Credit: Thermo Fisher Scientific

Specifically, he uses FAIMS as a front-end filter for targeted analyses in which he already knows what he's looking for. He sets the CV to transmit a particular class of ions, reducing chemical noise and increasing the signal-to-noise ratio in the process.

Despite the added information and separation it provides, IMS is not a high-resolution technique. Researchers can improve the resolution of conventional IMS by adjusting three parameters: increasing the drift tube length, lowering the temperature, and raising the drift gas pressure. Unfortunately, attempts to improve Synapt's resolution, which is about one-third that of conventional drift tubes, have failed thus far. "Intrinsic factors that aren't clearly understood seem to limit its resolution," Bowers says.

Some researchers, including Bowers; David E. Clemmer of Indiana University, Bloomington; and David H. Russell of Texas A&M University, are building drift tubes as long as 3 meters to improve the mobility resolution. Such long drift tubes might seem impractical, but "practicality is based on the utility," Russell says. "If we show that ion mobility can really do the things that some of us are claiming it can do, I think you would find chemistry departments converting elevator shafts into areas where you build long mobility devices."

Bowers finds that the most practical way to adjust resolution is through a combination of length and pressure. His group has settled on a 2-meter tube operated at 15 torr.

Russell is developing cryogenic IMS to improve resolution. As the temperature drops, different conformations "freeze out," he says. Peaks coalesce and separate as the temperature rises and falls, respectively. The technological challenge lies in cooling a 1- to 3-meter metal tube to liquid-nitrogen temperatures. "You really want to lower the temperature of the bath gas," Russell says, "but you also have to lower the temperature of the surroundings." If the liquid nitrogen experiments ever work as hoped—his group has worked on them for the better part of a decade—Russell will try to push the temperature even lower to liquid-helium temperatures.

McLean advocates variable-temperature IMS/MS, not just as a way to improve resolution but also to get new kinds of information. "When you do separations as a function of temperature, you can pull out thermodynamic and kinetic data for structural changes," he says.

AS THE RESOLUTION improves, the spectra may start to expose hidden fine structure indicating new conformations, Clemmer says. For example, his team originally saw three structures of the protein ubiquitin???compact, partially folded, and elongated. When they used a 3-meter drift tube, the added resolution revealed multiple states buried within the three broader peaks, including at least 10 states within the compact one. "There still may be states that aren't resolved in these substates," Clemmer says.

Although the Synapt system can't measure collision cross sections directly, it is nonetheless being used to calculate cross sections and determine molecular conformations. Some researchers worry about the accuracy of the calibrations used to draw these connections.

Ruotolo points out that mass spectrometrists are accustomed to calibrating their instruments. Calibrations "take away day-to-day fluctuations by always comparing your analysis with a 'known' of some kind," he says. "The main problem is that we don't have ideal calibrants. Once we get a good set of known values, there will be no barrier to anybody calibrating."

Ruotolo believes ideal calibrants should have a cross section that is unchanged by instrument parameters. "This rules out a lot of proteins. Proteins can change their overall size pretty easily just by varying the amount of internal energy they have or the amount of time they spend in the instrument," he says. However, Ruotolo notes, unfolded protein structures with high-charge states don't vary as much. He suggests that carbon clusters might make good standards.

Regardless of the standards used, calibration requires careful notation of the instrumental conditions. "If you are going to publish a calibration dataset, you also have to publish very precise instrument conditions that go along with each of those ions," Ruotolo says. "If you run the instrument in a different mode or use different amounts of activation energy, you'll get a completely different cross section."

For now, the key is careful selection of your research questions, Ruotolo says. Robinson's group, for instance, uses Synapt to determine conformational changes of as much as 30 or 40% in large protein assemblies. "If you take the error out of the equation by looking at things that can only be one thing or the other, given a set of models or situations, you make your life a lot easier," Ruotolo says. "Choose your problem such that your approach can actually solve the problem. Don't get into situations where your approach introduces more problems."

People must be careful when they report collision cross sections determined with Synapt, Bowers says. "There's definite curvature in these calibration plots. They're not linear," he says. "If you want absolute cross section, you've got to be sure that you're comparing to well-measured absolute cross sections." Bowers thinks, however, the problem won't affect most people who use the Synapt system because their questions don't demand that level of precision. "You can certainly get qualitative and semiquantitative cross sections," he says.

Clemmer points out that calibrating a low-mobility-resolution instrument such as Synapt against data from conventional instruments with higher resolution can be confusing. If higher resolution instruments reveal fine structures that Synapt can't resolve, "what do you calibrate to?" Clemmer asks. "If you're within a few percent, that's what the instrument can give."

Waters' goal in developing the Synapt system was making sure that the inherent low duty cycle of traditional IMS methods did not compromise the performance of the mass spectrometer. "We felt that we needed to offer this exciting capability in such a way that we didn't detrimentally affect the base sensitivity of the mass spectrometer," says Alan Millar, senior product manager at Waters. To maintain that sensitivity, the company focused on technology it already knew well, having used traveling-wave ion guides in other mass spectrometers.

[+]Enlarge
Sharper Image
Images based on mobility and mass (MALDI-IM-MS) are able to distinguish between a peptide (green) and a lipid (blue) of the same nominal mass spotted on liver tissue. The image based on mass alone (MALDI-MS) shows an X shape, but images that combine mass and drift time (ATD) reveal individual lines.
Credit: Adapted from J. Mass Spectrom.
8637cov_live-7
 
Sharper Image
Images based on mobility and mass (MALDI-IM-MS) are able to distinguish between a peptide (green) and a lipid (blue) of the same nominal mass spotted on liver tissue. The image based on mass alone (MALDI-MS) shows an X shape, but images that combine mass and drift time (ATD) reveal individual lines.
Credit: Adapted from J. Mass Spectrom.

ONE CHALLENGE with IMS is increasing the number of ions that are analyzed. Because it is a pulsed method, IMS duty cycle issues can result in many ions being discarded while waiting for previously injected ions to separate. Even those ions that make it into the drift tube can be lost because the ions diffuse radially as they travel through the device. Without a device to refocus the ions, less than 1% of the ions would reach the mass spectrometer. Synapt addresses those duty cycle issues by incorporating additional T-wave devices that trap and transfer the ions with minimal loss.

Many people attribute the current success of IMS to the ion funnels developed by Smith and coworkers that gently refocus those diffusing ions onto the exit and entrance apertures of the drift tube and the mass spectrometer. The funnels ensure that nearly all the ions are captured. The funnels, however, work best at low pressures, in the 1- to 25-torr range. "It would be nice to work at atmospheric pressure because you get better separations," Smith says. But "the ion funnel doesn't work at atmospheric pressure. We had to compromise," he adds.

Even in systems where most ions are being analyzed, much time can be wasted waiting for one batch of ions to clear the drift tube before injecting the next batch. Smith's group is working on this problem, as well. They have developed multiplexing methods in which they inject as many as 50 batches of ions before the first batch has exited the drift tube. "It takes an algorithm and a mathematical approach to deconvolute the overlapping distributions of ions and recover all that information," Smith says.

Yost believes that in the long run the major use of FAIMS and IMS will be as a separation device in front of a mass spectrometer, alone or in combination with liquid chromatography. "It's going to give you an extra stage of cleanup along the way that costs you nothing in time because it's essentially instantaneous," he says. In addition, the methods add selectivity to an analysis without hurting sensitivity. Finally, Yost says, these devices should be relatively inexpensive. The "killer application" that will make IMS and FAIMS an analytical must-have is yet to be identified, he says.

Although Bowers gives Waters ample credit for taking the leap to commercialize an IMS/MS system, he continues to hope that some company will commercialize an IMS/MS system with a conventional drift cell to enable higher resolution and the determination of absolute cross sections. With the absolute cross sections, companies could then include modeling capabilities in their software packages.

"We're in the ascendancy of this technique," he says. "We've got to get commercial instruments that are based on drift technology to the community. People aren't going to build them themselves."

 
Chemical & Engineering News
ISSN 0009-2347
Copyright © American Chemical Society