Volume 94 Issue 47 | p. 7 | News of The Week
Issue Date: November 28, 2016 | Web Date: November 24, 2016

Protein provides new route to carbon-silicon bonds

Bacterial cytochrome c demonstrates first example of biologically catalyzed organosilicon chemistry
Department: Science & Technology
News Channels: Organic SCENE, Biological SCENE, Materials SCENE
Keywords: biocatalysis, biochemistry, biological chemistry, biotechnology, synthesis, directed evolution, saturated mutagenesis, cytochrome c, organosilicon
[+]Enlarge
The heme group (blue) of R. marinus cytochrome c catalyzes carbenoid insertion into Si-H bonds.
Credit: Science
Image of the heme active site of R. marinus cytochrome c.
 
The heme group (blue) of R. marinus cytochrome c catalyzes carbenoid insertion into Si-H bonds.
Credit: Science

Silicon is the second most abundant element in Earth’s crust after oxygen, but carbon-silicon bonds are unheard of in nature: Neither biological organosilicon compounds nor biosynthetic pathways to create them have been identified. But when given the right starting materials, some heme proteins can stereospecifically form carbon-silicon bonds, report researchers from Caltech (Science 2016, DOI: 10.1126/science.aah6219).

“Nature’s iron heme chemistry just jumps on this opportunity because we provided it with the right precursors,” says Frances H. Arnold, who led the work with S. B. Jennifer Kan. “It’s a profound demonstration of how easily nature can innovate.”

[+]Enlarge
Three mutations of R. marinus cytochrome c turn the protein into an enzyme that produces organosilicon compounds with greater than 99% enantiomeric excess.
Credit: Science
Reaction scheme for heme-catalyzed carbenoid insertion into C-Si bonds.
 
Three mutations of R. marinus cytochrome c turn the protein into an enzyme that produces organosilicon compounds with greater than 99% enantiomeric excess.
Credit: Science

“This closes a crucial gap between biological and chemical catalysis,” writes Martin Oestreich of the Technical University of Berlin in a commentary accompanying the paper. “The impact is unforeseeable, but it seems that we are a big step closer to potentially facilitating industrially relevant reactions such as alkene hydrosilylation with biomolecules.”

Chemists have experimented for decades with forming chiral organosilicon compounds by carbenoid insertion into Si–H bonds, but the reactions typically require halogenated solvents and catalysts made of precious metals coordinated with chiral ligands. The catalysts also have low turnover—each catalyst complex survives fewer than 100 reactions before it inactivates.

Prior work in Arnold’s lab and elsewhere had demonstrated that heme proteins can catalyze nonnatural carbene transfer reactions through insertion into N–H and S–H bonds. In the new experiments, the researchers screened a panel of heme proteins to find ones that could catalyze insertion of ethyl 2-diazopropanoate into the Si–H bond of dimethyl(phenyl)silane. Cytochrome c from the bacterium Rhodothermus marinus, which is found in submarine hot springs in Iceland, catalyzed the reaction with 97% enantiomeric excess, although the catalytic turnover was still low.

Cytochrome c proteins normally don’t catalyze chemical reactions; instead they transfer electrons between biomolecules in cells. But that did not stop Kan, Arnold, and colleagues from pushing the R. marinus cytochrome c to improve its newfound ability to perform organosilicon catalysis.

The researchers used directed evolution to come up with a set of three mutations that together increase the new enzyme’s enantioselectivity to greater than 99% and turnover to greater than 1,500. One of the mutations involved a methionine residue that provides an axial ligand to the protein’s iron center. A change from methionine to aspartic acid possibly provided more substrate access for the formation of an iron-carbenoid intermediate.

The “evolved” cytochrome c performs stereoselective carbene insertion into Si–H bonds using a variety of silicon and diazo reagents, without competing cyclopropanation. And when given 4-(dimethylsilyl)aniline, which can accommodate insertion at both N–H and Si–H bonds, the enzyme formed the organosilicon product with 97% chemoselectivity. Arnold thinks that the partially exposed active site promotes substrate promiscuity but that there’s also some characteristic of the heme pocket that prefers silicon chemistry.

 
Chemical & Engineering News
ISSN 0009-2347
Copyright © American Chemical Society
Comments
Richard H. Fish (Thu Dec 01 12:55:37 EST 2016)
This shows that organometallic chemistry is compatible with biocatalysis. We and others have also shown that organometallic hydrides and biomimetic co-factors are able to provide 1,4-NADH biomimics that can reduce the FAD component of Cytochrome C to FADH2 on the e-pathway to reduce Fe(III) to Fe(II) to bind O2 or a carbene. Perhaps Arnold et al can expand this new paradigm to other metal hydrides such as R3SnH in Group 4 with Si. Organotin hydrides are much more reactive and the ease of biocatalysts to provide chiral Sn-H compounds for chiral synthetic applications would be exciting!
Leave A Comment